business, strategy, technology, tesla John Dinsmore business, strategy, technology, tesla John Dinsmore

Will Somebody Please Marry Elon Musk?!?! The Financial Case for Apple Buying Tesla

As we head in to the summer, it is angst-provoking that I—the biggest Elon Musk fanboy there is—need to start thinking about Tesla being sold. Elon’s brilliance and ambition have accomplished unthinkable things—but they have also caused him to over-lever and over-expand his company. Tesla needs Elon Musk. But Elon Musk needs help.

In general, people think either a big tech company or a big auto company would be the likely partner/acquirer. In terms of culture, philosophy, and geography, Tesla is much more a tech company than a car company. Apple probably makes the most sense here.

Strategically, Apple needs a new high-growth platform now that the smartphone industry is mature. They abandoned the idea of making cars a couple of years ago, but continue to flirt with tech related to it. And, a purchase of Tesla is not just a way to enter the fast-growing electric car market. It’s also a way to enter the high-growth green energy, energy storage, Internet of Things, and artificial intelligence markets. Markets where Tesla has leadership positions.

But what about the financial case? As of this moment, Tesla is valued at about $33.5 billion. Apple is valued at more than 25 times that and could nearly pay cash for the company. If you look at Tesla’s last <<disastrous>> quarter, the company lost $728 Million. Most of that loss could be covered by dramatically reducing Selling, General & Administrative (SGA, $703M), Research & Development (R&D, $340M) and interest expense ($157) million.

In joining the two companies, Tim Cook could reduce redundancies in SG&A and R&D between the two. It could retire the high interest debt that Tesla currently has to service and then scale the operations of Tesla appropriately to make the company economically sustainable. AND, perhaps best of all, it could tell Elon Musk “no” when it had to.

As with any marriage, sometimes the most valuable thing a partner can do is tell us the things we least want to hear. And Elon Musk needs that desperately.

Read More
strategy, technology, marketing John Dinsmore strategy, technology, marketing John Dinsmore

So long as Tesla's not too proud, they're current financing issue shouldn't be a problem

The only thing standing between Tesla and sustainable financing is pride. 

Tesla burned through $675 Million in cash last quarter and they only have $3.3 Billion on hand. So there has been a lot of talk Tesla maybe running out of gas before it can realize its vision. 

The revenue numbers don't lie, but they only tell a very small part of the story. Here are some other numbers: 

Could they run out of money? Yes. Will they? It depends on how much pride Musk has. In order to facilitate it's many lines of business, Tesla should mitigate it's financial liabilities by pursuing joint ventures in its many non-core lines of business--batteries, solar, trucks. By doing so, they can limit their liabilities, receive an infusion of needed cash and take on the complementary assets of joint venture partners. 

For instance, if Tesla were to partner with Peterbilt or Mack on its electric semi, it would get a lot more than just cash. Tesla would receive: 

* Manufacturing expertise and infrastructure

* Sales personnel, expertise and relationships in the trucking industry. 

Tesla could design and innovate. Peterbilt/Mack could manufacture and sell. And for this, Tesla would have to surrender a significant cut of revenue but it could capture more market share faster than it would be able to on its own. If Musk is open to these trade-offs, it would solve a whole host of problems. Similar partnerships would be available for other lines of business. For instance, perhaps partnering the solar business with a large, luxury home builder like Toll Brothers. 

The question is: is Musk more interested in being "the man" or is he more interested in winning? We'll soon find out. 

Read More