business, strategy, technology, tesla John Dinsmore business, strategy, technology, tesla John Dinsmore

Will Somebody Please Marry Elon Musk?!?! The Financial Case for Apple Buying Tesla

As we head in to the summer, it is angst-provoking that I—the biggest Elon Musk fanboy there is—need to start thinking about Tesla being sold. Elon’s brilliance and ambition have accomplished unthinkable things—but they have also caused him to over-lever and over-expand his company. Tesla needs Elon Musk. But Elon Musk needs help.

In general, people think either a big tech company or a big auto company would be the likely partner/acquirer. In terms of culture, philosophy, and geography, Tesla is much more a tech company than a car company. Apple probably makes the most sense here.

Strategically, Apple needs a new high-growth platform now that the smartphone industry is mature. They abandoned the idea of making cars a couple of years ago, but continue to flirt with tech related to it. And, a purchase of Tesla is not just a way to enter the fast-growing electric car market. It’s also a way to enter the high-growth green energy, energy storage, Internet of Things, and artificial intelligence markets. Markets where Tesla has leadership positions.

But what about the financial case? As of this moment, Tesla is valued at about $33.5 billion. Apple is valued at more than 25 times that and could nearly pay cash for the company. If you look at Tesla’s last <<disastrous>> quarter, the company lost $728 Million. Most of that loss could be covered by dramatically reducing Selling, General & Administrative (SGA, $703M), Research & Development (R&D, $340M) and interest expense ($157) million.

In joining the two companies, Tim Cook could reduce redundancies in SG&A and R&D between the two. It could retire the high interest debt that Tesla currently has to service and then scale the operations of Tesla appropriately to make the company economically sustainable. AND, perhaps best of all, it could tell Elon Musk “no” when it had to.

As with any marriage, sometimes the most valuable thing a partner can do is tell us the things we least want to hear. And Elon Musk needs that desperately.

Read More
business, strategy, corporate regulation John Dinsmore business, strategy, corporate regulation John Dinsmore

We Need a Federal Law Banning Corporations Like Amazon from Shaking Down Localities

It’s time for a national law eliminating bidding wars with public money to lure companies

Abe Polin, the late owner of the Washington Wizards and Washington Capitals, was once asked why he didn’t seek public money for the coliseums in which his teams played. Looking offended at the question, he said, “You don’t think I can afford it?”

But, that was a long time ago. Tycoons no longer take pride in their ability to move mountains with their own resources and champion the communities in which they live. Now, they take pride in extracting resources from these communities—strip mining them and laying them bare and emaciated.

Sports team owners started the trend of taking highly profitable businesses and leveraging their political capital of these teams’ popularity to get public money for stadiums. But over the last 20 years, corporations have taken up the initiative. Here in Dayton, NCR and its spin-off Teradata have spurned the communities that have embraced them for decades. Instead, they sold their headquarter locations off to the towns willing to empty the public coffers to lure them there. Amazon is the latest and perhaps largest company in this trend.

Between NCR, Teradata, and Amazon, they have attracted billions in public money to locate their companies in Atlanta, San Diego, New York City, and Washington DC respectively —towns which they almost assuredly would have located regardless. So, the rich markets are getting richer while the small and mid-size markets are being pillaged.

This is public money being taken away from crumbling infrastructure and struggling education systems.

Further, in the instance of FoxConn bringing a manufacturing facility to Wisconsin for $3 Billion in public money, the result is not higher employment of locals, but importation of foreign nationals to perform the work. Other times, the jobs brought are so low wage, that further subsidies are required for employees in the form of welfare and food stamps. The benefits of these subsidies to the CEOs and shareholders are staggering, while the benefits to the communities almost never live up to expectations.

But, politicians have been, and always will be, eager to write these checks so they can claim to be wizards at job creation. And, with the next town over always willing to play the patsy and offer money, there is no way any state or local law will keep this practice in check.

So, we need a federal law capping these incentives to save localities from themselves. The law should limit the amount and types of infrastructure investment specific to a corporate location being allowed. Discretion and honor being left in the hands of billionaires and politicians is a fool’s errand. Common sense limits on these subsidies will not cost jobs and put more money in to public resources like education that will grow our economy much more than having a new warehouse or call center come to your town.

Read More
strategy, technology, marketing John Dinsmore strategy, technology, marketing John Dinsmore

So long as Tesla's not too proud, they're current financing issue shouldn't be a problem

The only thing standing between Tesla and sustainable financing is pride. 

Tesla burned through $675 Million in cash last quarter and they only have $3.3 Billion on hand. So there has been a lot of talk Tesla maybe running out of gas before it can realize its vision. 

The revenue numbers don't lie, but they only tell a very small part of the story. Here are some other numbers: 

Could they run out of money? Yes. Will they? It depends on how much pride Musk has. In order to facilitate it's many lines of business, Tesla should mitigate it's financial liabilities by pursuing joint ventures in its many non-core lines of business--batteries, solar, trucks. By doing so, they can limit their liabilities, receive an infusion of needed cash and take on the complementary assets of joint venture partners. 

For instance, if Tesla were to partner with Peterbilt or Mack on its electric semi, it would get a lot more than just cash. Tesla would receive: 

* Manufacturing expertise and infrastructure

* Sales personnel, expertise and relationships in the trucking industry. 

Tesla could design and innovate. Peterbilt/Mack could manufacture and sell. And for this, Tesla would have to surrender a significant cut of revenue but it could capture more market share faster than it would be able to on its own. If Musk is open to these trade-offs, it would solve a whole host of problems. Similar partnerships would be available for other lines of business. For instance, perhaps partnering the solar business with a large, luxury home builder like Toll Brothers. 

The question is: is Musk more interested in being "the man" or is he more interested in winning? We'll soon find out. 

Read More
marketing, business, strategy, technology John Dinsmore marketing, business, strategy, technology John Dinsmore

A Classical Market Analysis of Bitcoin Using Porter's Five Forces

A market analysis shows some rough seas ahead for Bitcoin

The surge of Bitcoin value has caused a global frenzy of investing in, and mining of, Bitcoin. Fortune even published an article about the growing phenomenon of people mortgaging their homes to invest in Bitcoin. It is eerily similar to stories in the late 90s where people were quitting their jobs and mortgaging their homes to invest in Internet stocks--and that did not turnout all sunshine and daisies. 

And, similar to Internet stocks, I think there's going to be a few winners and a whole lot of losers when it comes to cryptocurrency. 

Bitcoin was ingeniously designed to provide privacy, security and scarcity of its currency. It's value is largely derived from those three attributes. One additional--and currently most significant--source of its value is the brand equity/publicity Bitcoin enjoys as a rapidly appreciating investment. So, what could go wrong?

In a classical marketing context, I would look at Porter's five forces of profitability to try and determine the long term value of Bitcoin. Here goes: 

Threat of Substitutes, Threat of New Entrants, Competitive Rivalry: The notoriety of Bitcoin is attracting legions of potential substitutes. From software companies to banks, everyone is getting into the act. Bitcoin is, by far, the leader in the space. While it has brilliantly managed its own scarcity, Bitcoin can't manage the scarcity of currency in general. Plus, at the end of the day, software companies, banks and governments can back their currencies with assets. Bitcoin is backed only by goodwill. And, when the fever dies down, users of currency may want some harder guarantees than Bitcoin can provide. 

Bargaining Power of Customers: For the reasons stated above, users of currency are going to have A LOT of options available to them. And when it comes to use of currency (rather than investing in it), the Bitcoin value proposition is not that strong unless you are trying to avoid detection of your transactions by the government. 

Bargaining Power of Suppliers: So, who are the suppliers to Bitcoin and other currencies? Well, there's a lot of them. You have the miners of Bitcoin. You also have merchants who are willing to accept Bitcoin or another currency as payment. And both of these groups are likely to stumble into some stiff government regulation pretty soon. Here are just a few of the reasons: 

As part of this, governments (particularly corrupt ones) are in a unique position to manipulate the value of Bitcoin. Take a short position on Bitcoin, then shut down or suspend Bitcoin acceptance in your country, and cash in. 

And, as Bitcoin becomes a regulated currency it loses a lot of the attributes (namely, privacy) that attract people to it. 

Short term, I hope everyone makes a lot of money on Bitcoin. Long-term, you probably need to find another investment. 

Read More
business, marketing, strategy, technology John Dinsmore business, marketing, strategy, technology John Dinsmore

Why Uber Does Not Have a Sustainable Business Model

First off, allow me to say: I love Uber. Or, should I say, I lover Ubering.

Here in Dayton, Ohio, there are about three cabs for the entire market. The introduction of Uber and--finally--Lyft, have been a godsend for getting to the airport, meeting friends out for happy hour or, in my case, getting your kid to preschool when you can't find your car keys. It's a useful service that delivers a societal benefit. 

So, while Ubering will always be around, it's hard to see Uber being the dominant force Wall Street seems to think it will. Here's why: 

1. Lack of differentiation creating pricing pressure: Currently. there only seems to be two ways to differentiate ride-sharing services--brand and distribution. While Uber and Lyft are attempting to segment the market by types of car, ability to carpool, etc., each of these segmentation attempts is easily replicated. In fact, the lack of differentiation not only exists for customers, it also exists for drivers where many drivers drive for both Uber and Lyft, taking only the best fares. 

This lack of differentiation leaves you only to compete on price in a dreaded "race to the bottom." This is a key reason Uber exited China, joining Chinese ride-sharing giant Didi Chuxing rather than trying to beat it. Thus far, it seems the only way to profitably run a ride-sharing service is to monopolize markets and eliminate pricing pressure from both passengers and drivers. 

2. Uber fares are artificially low. The company spends a large portion of the funds it raises to subsidize fares and drivers as a means of promotion. Once, the promotional funds run dry--fares are going to come up.

To escape a lot of overhead, the company has been aggressive in maintaining the position that its drivers are not employees and do not require the same regulations as taxi drivers. They continue to lose court cases on this front. And, with drivers having to be treated as employees who are subject to the same regulations as taxi drivers, that represents a huge increase in overhead. Fares are going to come up. 

3. Ride-sharing technology is not hard to duplicate. What you needs to make this business run are passengers and drivers. To get either, you need name recognition and a workable app to connect the two parties and handle payments. At this point, name recognition is harder to achieve than having a workable app. Taxi companies have comparable apps to Uber.  You are going to see a lot more local players better local exposure and market knowledge private-labeling 3rd party apps and getting into this space.

If there is a business that reminds me of Uber, it's Groupon. A middleman service connecting buyers to sellers where the buyers are only loyal to the 'deal', or in the case of Uber, the lowest fare. 

 

Read More
marketing, strategy, technology, streaming John Dinsmore marketing, strategy, technology, streaming John Dinsmore

Nobody can pull of the switch!!!! Roku just did

The CEO of Roku has just pulled off the all-time switch. 

Roku just pulled off the switch. In their first earnings statement since the company went public, the company announced blockbuster growth.

The CEO (pictured above ;-p ) has transformed the company from a product company that sold a streaming stick to a services company the provides an operating system for televisions. 

There are a great many companies who have attempted such a thing. Some--like IBM--have done so successfully. For others--like Microsoft--the verdict is less clear. But for Roku, their move has accomplished a few things: 

1. They are getting out of the business of retro-fitting older TVs for streaming with their hardware and instead are providing an operating system for newer TVs with their software. Software--especially through licensing and OEM agreements--scales more easily and is more profitable than hardware. 

2. The are moving out of a business orientated toward a single sale to one where they can generate highly frequency sales of content through their platform. 

3. Their unique positioning as the only streaming platform that doesn't also own/sell content directly has placed them as the platform with whom all content and TV makers can get along. For instance, Amazon sells streaming sticks AND content. They only allow integration of Amazon content with two platforms--Amazon Fire and Roku (I say this as very bummed Prime subscriber with a Chromecast stick). 

If Roku keeps up this momentum, they may well create a network effect akin to Microsoft Windows in the mid-90s. The more TV manufacturers they get OEM agreements with, the more content providers will integrate with Roku. The more content providers that integrate with Roku, the more TV manufacturers that will sign OEM agreements. Very shrewd and well-executed on their part. 

Read More
business, strategy, consumer behavior, mobile John Dinsmore business, strategy, consumer behavior, mobile John Dinsmore

The Great Lesson of the iPhone 8

Apple's release of the iPhone models 8 and X together provides one of the great marketing lessons of the year. 

In hopes of commemorating the 10th anniversary of the product that still comprises the majority of Apple's earnings, Apple decided to release is a special model (iPhone X) along with its more regular, sequential successor to the iPhone 7 (iPhone 8). The problem? Products are not evaluated in a vacuum. They are evaluated in connection to a reference point. (The great Dan Ariely gives a fantastic TED talk on this principle.)

As a result, the iPhone 8 does not seem all that new or leading-edge and demand has been poor as people have decided to wait and pay extra for the iPhone X. The iPhone x, however? Demand is amazing as it's juxtaposition to the 8 makes it seem even more upscale. 

Chances are, Apple was worried about only having a $1,000+ model on the market. But if the 8 continues to push demand for the X, the investment in the 8 will have paid off handsomely. 

Read More
business, marketing, strategy, dayton, ohio John Dinsmore business, marketing, strategy, dayton, ohio John Dinsmore

The never-ending process of marketing...Insights-Action-Results-Repeat

Whether it's talking to students or clients, there is one common misconception of marketing: Once you develop a marketing plan to launch a company, that's kinda it. You launch. You declare victory. And then, you retire to your yacht with untold riches. 

But the truth is much more daunting. The process of marketing never ends. There is always a next step to take with your customers and prospects. When someone makes a purchase from you, that's just the beginning of your relationship. And, like all relationships, you have to work to enhance and preserve that relationship so that it stands the tests of time and inevitable change. So, what is the process of marketing?

INSIGHTS: Learn all you can about you market. Many of these sources of information can be informal such as: conversations you've had customers, prospects, partners or news articles and blogs from people you respects. Other sources can be more formal: research reports from secondary sources, analysis of internal data or proprietary market research you conduct. 

ACTION: From this intelligence you've gathered, there should actions that need to be taken. And, in many cases, the intelligence will SCREAM at you to employ certain tactics. In other cases, the intel's inferences may be more subtle. But either way, you have become smarter about your business and now you must put that newfound intellectual capital to work. Inaction, in this instance, would equal malpractice. 

RESULTS: Once you have implemented these actions, you must be very careful to document and measure your actual results and compare them to the results you expected prior to taking actions. Spoiler alert: You will be wrong to some degree. You could be wrong in a very pleasant way and surpass you expectations. Even so, connecting your intel to actions and comparing what you thought would happen with what actually happen is the first step in generating intelligence for the next go around. 

REPEAT: As you learn from the results, you will acquire new knowledge. You will also identify gaps in your knowledge of which you had been unaware. As you re-enter the Insight phase, work to fill those gaps and apply the knowledge you gained from the results of your last campaign. 

 

Read More