Will Somebody Please Marry Elon Musk?!?! The Financial Case for Apple Buying Tesla
As we head in to the summer, it is angst-provoking that I—the biggest Elon Musk fanboy there is—need to start thinking about Tesla being sold. Elon’s brilliance and ambition have accomplished unthinkable things—but they have also caused him to over-lever and over-expand his company. Tesla needs Elon Musk. But Elon Musk needs help.
In general, people think either a big tech company or a big auto company would be the likely partner/acquirer. In terms of culture, philosophy, and geography, Tesla is much more a tech company than a car company. Apple probably makes the most sense here.
Strategically, Apple needs a new high-growth platform now that the smartphone industry is mature. They abandoned the idea of making cars a couple of years ago, but continue to flirt with tech related to it. And, a purchase of Tesla is not just a way to enter the fast-growing electric car market. It’s also a way to enter the high-growth green energy, energy storage, Internet of Things, and artificial intelligence markets. Markets where Tesla has leadership positions.
But what about the financial case? As of this moment, Tesla is valued at about $33.5 billion. Apple is valued at more than 25 times that and could nearly pay cash for the company. If you look at Tesla’s last <<disastrous>> quarter, the company lost $728 Million. Most of that loss could be covered by dramatically reducing Selling, General & Administrative (SGA, $703M), Research & Development (R&D, $340M) and interest expense ($157) million.
In joining the two companies, Tim Cook could reduce redundancies in SG&A and R&D between the two. It could retire the high interest debt that Tesla currently has to service and then scale the operations of Tesla appropriately to make the company economically sustainable. AND, perhaps best of all, it could tell Elon Musk “no” when it had to.
As with any marriage, sometimes the most valuable thing a partner can do is tell us the things we least want to hear. And Elon Musk needs that desperately.
Sea Change: WalMart Surpassing Apple in Mobile Payments
What's exciting about following the world of tech and mobile are those moments when the market finally coalesces around a "winner."
Despite huge amounts invested in the effort, Apple appears to be losing ground in mobile payments and is about to be overtaken by WalMart. But, the big question is, why?
If this were a marketing case, you'd want to do a "Willingness-to-Pay" (WTP) analysis between ApplePay and WalMart's payment app. Here's a great overview of WTP. In that analysis, you do frame your product in two different ways:
1. What could I add to my product that would raise a customer's willingness to pay for or use the product?
2. What aspects of my product that I am paying for DO NOT raise my customer's WTP.
And an example they use is Tastycake. They had not been using preservatives in their snack cakes. But, since they are in the business of perishable foods, that meant they had to replace a lot of stock in stores. This required a lot of product and a lot of labor to take the new product out to stores. Tastycake realized that their customers didn't care about preservatives. SO, they added them and had to replace a lot less stock and send a lot fewer trucks out to stores.
WalMart's app is incredibly useful--you can remote order, pre-pay, access deals and more. ApplePay is. . . well. . . already on your phone. That's an advantage but it's not enough on its own.
The early indication is that retailers, not handset makers will win the mobile payment wars. Starbucks and Taco Bell are also big winners on this front. Unless handset makers can find new ways to add value to payments (discounts, services, etc.), it's going to be a very tough road.
The Great Lesson of the iPhone 8
Apple's release of the iPhone models 8 and X together provides one of the great marketing lessons of the year.
In hopes of commemorating the 10th anniversary of the product that still comprises the majority of Apple's earnings, Apple decided to release is a special model (iPhone X) along with its more regular, sequential successor to the iPhone 7 (iPhone 8). The problem? Products are not evaluated in a vacuum. They are evaluated in connection to a reference point. (The great Dan Ariely gives a fantastic TED talk on this principle.)
As a result, the iPhone 8 does not seem all that new or leading-edge and demand has been poor as people have decided to wait and pay extra for the iPhone X. The iPhone x, however? Demand is amazing as it's juxtaposition to the 8 makes it seem even more upscale.
Chances are, Apple was worried about only having a $1,000+ model on the market. But if the 8 continues to push demand for the X, the investment in the 8 will have paid off handsomely.