marketing, social media John Dinsmore marketing, social media John Dinsmore

"Follower Factory" New York Times Piece Shows in Marketing, as in Politics, Be Wary of Those Offering Easy Answers

The recent New York Times feature on a company selling Twitter followers highlights that many "social media gurus" aren't any better at generating influence than your average person. 

The recent New York Times feature "The Follower Factory" on a company selling Twitter followers highlights that many "social media gurus" aren't any better at generating influence than your average person. The article is well worth the read, but one part really stands out: 

Jeetendr Sehdev, a former adjunct professor at the University of Southern California who calls himself “the world’s leading celebrity branding authority,” began buying hundreds of thousands of fake followers from Devumi.

He did not respond to requests for comment. But in his recent best-selling book, “The Kim Kardashian Principle: Why Shameless Sells,” he had a different explanation for his rising follower count. “My social media following exploded,” Mr. Sehdev claimed, because he had discovered the true secret to celebrity influence: “Authenticity is the key.”

I saw another marketing professor focus on this passage as well. It's both hilarious and shameful at the same time. Yes, authenticity is a factor in online influence. But, it's far from the only factor. But, if you want to start breaking out the dozens of factors generating online influence, well, then your story becomes a lot more tiring to followers, prospects, clients and publishers. Better just to buy a bunch of fake followers and say "Look at me, I'm an influencer!"

Too often in marketing, as in life, we find the the simplest solutions are the most persuasive. But the truth is, persistent problems--whether it's peace in the Middle East or marketing your company--persist because they are difficult to solve. If there was a single key to solving these problems, we would all have solved them. Like a fad diet plan, marketing books and consulting pitches become less persuasive the more you confront the truth: Marketing is a complex problem and continual process that requires time, money and effort. Full stop. End of story. 

 

 

Read More

Fixing Facebook...What Zuckerberg is Missing

Mark Zuckerberg is right when he says he needs to fix Facebook. But he's wrong about how to fix it. 

Mark Zuckerberg announced that his 2018 New Year's resolution was to "fix Facebook." But, based on his comments, it seems he's taking too narrow a view of what needs to be done. 

After revelations that Facebook was the platform of choice for Russian hackers to influence the presidential election, it seems a patriotic choice for the CEO of Facebook. However, he also has a business reason: In an increasingly politicized environment with dark news cycles, depressing and contentious posts make Facebook less appealing. Engagement is down among users. And that lowering engagement could be the sign of a long-term trend. 

Zuckerberg's statements have focused on making news feeds tighter, focusing on posts from friends and de-emphasizing content from unknown, unconnected sources--including advertisers. At a high level, Zuckerberg is right. Long term, downward trends can be threaten the platform. Additionally, the loosy-goosy nature of the news feed algorithm made it easy prey for malicious parties. But tightening news feeds is not enough. 

Facebook also needs to perform textual analysis to discern tone of posts and the nature of interactions. The company can--and should--upgrade posts and connections which are more positive in nature. And this analysis does not need to create echo chambers of people who agree. You can create algorithms of people who disagree and debate in a respectful manner and enjoy their interactions. People will feel better and engage more in the platform. And believe it or not, making Facebook more positive place will also make people smarter. 

 

Read More